Human Biology Taking Sides #3
TAKING SIDES ANALYSIS
Name: Cheralyn Tate
Course: Human Biology
Book: Taking Sides readings
Issue number: 3 Title of issue:The Case Against Perfection
1. Author and major thesis of the Yes side .Michael Sandel; societies who would employ genetic enhancement in the pursuit of improving the next generation of children
2. Author and major thesis of the No side. Howard Trachtman
3. Briefly state in your own words two facts presented by each side. Yes side: Two deaf lesbians chose a deaf sperm-donor so that their child would be deaf. (They succeeded) I feel that both authors were lacking a lot of facts, and a lot of personal opinions. One example was a sentence stating that 40 percent of human growth-hormone prescriptions were “off-label” by 1996. I have no way of knowing if this is true, as the author provides no source for these minimal uses of “statistics” in this article.
-
Briefly state in your own words two opinions presented by each side. Yes side: "giftedness of human life" which holds that "our talents and powers are not wholly our own doing, nor even fully ours, despite the efforts we expend to develop and exercise them" and that "not everything in the world is [morally] open to any use we may desire or devise." Another example mentions how athletes abusing the drug erythropoietin does not detract from the qualitative improvement in the lives of patients with end stage renal disease who are treated with this drug. A statement that I found to be factual as it was both supported
No side: The opposing side offers a number of sourced facts, though some more closely resemble opinions supported by other articles. One example states that in the 1970’s, immunization practices and antibiotic administration became standard, decreasing cases of smallpox and polio.
5. Briefly identify as many fallacies(lack of reasoning or validity) on the Yes side as you can. "giftedness of human life" which holds that "our talents and powers are not wholly our own doing, nor even fully ours, despite the efforts we expend to develop and exercise them" and that "not everything in the world is [morally] open to any use we may desire or devise." , , "liberal eugenics does not reject state-imposed genetic engineering at all." class separation due to financial means is another.
6. Briefly identify as many fallacies on the No side as you can. Both opinions I previously mentioned from this article struck me as fallacies. Particularly the first talking about medical treatments never living up to what’s expected. That opinion has absolutely no evidence to back up this bold claim. That statement encompasses a very wide range of medical achievements. The author is suggesting that not a single one of these has ever been as beneficial as it was initially suggested to be. It just strikes me as being far too broad of a statement to be qualified in any degree.
-
All in all, which author impressed you as being the most empirical in presenting his or her thesis? Why?
-
I found Howard Trachtman’s article to be the more empirical of the two on the basis that he offered more sources for his thoughts. He qualified more of his facts and opinions. While the supportive article was more interesting for me to read, it just lacked authenticity in favor of unsupported opinions. .
8. Are there any reasons to believe the writers are biased? If so, why do they have these biases? Writers were biased because Sandel made his implications that the oppostion must be results from intellectual naiveness. He is a philosopher, the other author is a physician.
9. Which side (Yes or No) do you personally feel is most correct now that you have reviewed the material in these articles? Why?
I’m more inclined to lean towards the opinion that genetic enhancement is not an unacceptable use of technology. My basis for this opinion is that I believe technology should very much be used to explore advancements in many fields including biological science and the medical field. It is a dangerous path, and it’s easy to see how such exploration could go too far, but I do not see that as a strong enough reason to avoid the exploration altogether.
TAKING SIDES ANALYSIS (10 points) #2
Name: __Cheralyn Tate ____________________________________________________________________
Course: __Human Biology_________________________________________________________________
Book:__Taking Sides _________________________________________________________________
Issue number: _11____ Title of issue: Vaccination for HPV Be mandated for Teenage Girls
1. Author and major thesis of the Yes side: Joseph E Balog _A principle based approach to moral reasoning leads to the conclusion that compulsory HPV vaccinations for teenage girls can be justified on moral, scientific, and public health grounds.
2. Author and major thesis of the No side. _Gail Javit, Deena Berkowitz, Lawrence O Gostin Given the limited data and experience, and the fact that HPV does not pose significant risks to others, mandating HPV vaccine is premature.
3. Briefly state in your own words two facts presented by each side. Yes side, 3.2 million adolescent girls have STI's and 18.3% are infected with HPV. NO side, anti vaccination movements have been fueled by a general distrust of government, a rugged sense of individualism, and concerns about the safety of vaccines.
4. Briefly state in your own words two opinions presented by each side. Yes, compulsory vaccination program will better serve the at risk populations. No side, governments objection to cervical cancer and means to achieve it lacks sufficient rationality.
5. Briefly identify as many fallacies(lack of reasoning or validity) on the Yes side as you can. The author compares sexually transmitted infections and cancer to the severity of the polio outbreak of 1950s.
6. Briefly identify as many fallacies on the No side as you can. They mention examples of manufacturers withdrawing products from the market without giving specific examples _________________________________________________
7. All in all, which author impressed you as being the most empirical in presenting his or her thesis? Why?_the yes side, because there were more facts and figures to support the claims for the benefit of the vaccine.
8. Are there any reasons to believe the writers are biased? If so, why do they have these biases? The moral and political siding stated in both sides of the articles
9. Which side (Yes or No) do you personally feel is most correct now that you have reviewed the material in these articles? Why?
The yes side is based more on moral obligations than fact, no side is looking for more long term proof of the vaccines.